Results for objective indicia of non-obviousness

Liqwd, Inc. v. L’Oréal USA, Inc.

Case Number: CLB0443

Date: 10.20.2019

Although more evidence is needed than just showing a similarity between a patent and a competitor’s accused product to establish copying, all evidence of objective indicia is vital in determining the obviousness of a patented invention.

view Case Detail Download PDF

ZUP, LLC v. Nash Mfg., Inc.

Case Number: CLB0423

Date: 07.25.2018

A weak showing of both long-felt but unresolved need and copying cannot overcome a strong showing of obviousness set forth by predictable use of prior art elements according to established functions.

view Case Detail Download PDF